CrossFit athlete overcomes repeat shoulder injuries to reach semifinals: Sam’s story

Orthopaedics and Fitness
Patient Story
Sam Agostini in a low squat while holding a barbell with four large weights attached.

Samantha "Sam" Agostini, 32, played competitive sports throughout her childhood and enjoyed a successful career as a high school and collegiate volleyball player. When faced with a series of shoulder and knee injuries, she chose specialized orthopaedic sports medicine care at Main Line Health. Thanks to the careful treatment she received as a young volleyball player, Sam is now a CrossFit athlete competing nationally at the highest level.

A standout volleyball player

Sam was an athlete throughout her childhood and began playing volleyball year-round in high school.

"My position was opposite hitter and I'm a lefty, which is not super common in volleyball," says Sam. "It always helped the team because we had a hitter with a dominant hand on both sides of the court."

Sidelined by knee trouble

Sam was injury-free for most of her career, but all of that changed in her junior year on the women's volleyball team at West Chester University.

"During a match my teammate set the ball, and I ran in a little too quickly," recalls Sam. "I had to reach behind me for the hit and landed with all of my weight on my right leg, and my knee just buckled."

Main Line Health fellowship-trained sports medicine doctor, David L. Rubenstein, MD, had previously treated Sam for knee pain when she was in middle school. Facing another sports-related injury, she knew who to call.

Sports medicine for young athletes

Dr. Rubenstein arranged to see Sam in his office the next day and ordered an MRI that confirmed a meniscus tear in her knee. Soon afterward, he surgically repaired the tear at Lankenau Medical Center, part of Main Line Health in Wynnewood, PA.

"We know that for younger athletes in high school and college, like Sam, their entire lives revolve around sports," says Dr. Rubenstein. "We fit them in the day of their injury, or the next day."

Just a few days after her knee surgery, Sam was already doing bunny hops to test her mobility. Dr. Rubenstein prescribed physical therapy exercises to continue to strengthen her knee, which he coordinated with the trainers in the athletic department at Sam's school.

"The athletic trainers were our partners in treatment," says Dr. Rubenstein. "We communicated closely with them about Sam's diagnosis, surgery and when it was safe for her to return to competition."

Banner year ends in shoulder labral tear

Sam's knee healed quickly and she returned to volleyball. It was her senior year, and the West Chester Golden Rams enjoyed both a conference playoff run and an NCAA tournament appearance. After their final game, however, Sam started to feel the wear and tear on her shoulder.

"It was just a lot of volleyball and a lot of reps on my arm," says Sam. "By the end of the season, I couldn't feel my hand."

Sam returned to Dr. Rubenstein, who diagnosed her with a rip in the cartilage surrounding the socket of the shoulder joint, called a shoulder labral tear. This tear can cause shoulder pain and weakness, as well as hand numbness from inflammation that presses on nearby nerves. As Sam continued to compete in recreational volleyball tournaments post-college, she would tear her shoulder labrum two more times, totaling three tears in a span of just three years.

"It is incredibly common for young volleyball players to have repeat tears," explains Dr. Rubenstein. "The shoulder has the greatest range of motion of any joint in the body, and with repetitive overhead motion, the ball of the shoulder can slide out of the socket and tear the labrum cartilage."

Following each injury, Sam discussed all of the treatment options with Dr. Rubenstein, and each time she opted for surgical repair.

"I knew I wasn't done being an athlete," Sam says.

New sport tests shoulder strength

After Sam's third and final shoulder surgery, she was ready to transition to a new sport. She came across a documentary about CrossFit, a fitness program of high-intensity, constantly varied functional movements performed in coached workouts and competitions.

Upper body strength is fundamental to CrossFit as athletes attempt handstand walks and various overhead weight lifts like snatches, jerks and presses. If there were a sport that would test Sam's shoulder strength and stability, this was it.

"I remember watching the documentary and thinking, "I'm strong, I can do that,'" recalls Sam.

Competing nationally at highest level

Sam went to her first CrossFit class in 2019 and several years later began traveling around the country to compete in the CrossFit women's pro division. Her goal was to reach the semifinals that include the top 2,000 female athletes in the world. In the summer of 2026, she did just that.

"When I tell people I've had my labrum torn and repaired three times, they are shocked I can snatch 183 pounds over my head," says Sam. "I'm very grateful for everything my shoulder allows me to do."

Sports medicine for elite performance

Sam is grateful for the specialized sports injury care she received at Main Line Health, from her time as a young competitive athlete through her journey into CrossFit. She credits Dr. Rubenstein and Main Line Health's sports medicine services with helping her achieve her fitness goals.

"Dr. Rubenstein is very straightforward," says Sam. "He told me what was wrong, explained all of my options and made sure I understood everything. And I trusted him, which was huge."

"Sam had multiple surgeries before turning 30 but didn't let anything get in her way, and today she is competing at the highest level," says Dr. Rubenstein.

Next steps

Have you experienced sudden or chronic pain due to sports, exercise or other physical activity? Main Line Health's network of fellowship-trained sports medicine physicians, orthopaedic surgeons, like Dr. Rubenstein, and rehabilitation specialists provides comprehensive care for injuries and conditions that affect active lifestyles. Together, they help patients of all ages and activity levels recover from injury, regain function and safely return to the activities they enjoy most.

Schedule an appointment with David L. Rubenstein, MD

Learn more about sports medicine at Main Line Health.

Related posts

Debunking common myths about shoulder pain

Orthopaedic and sports rehab guide: Recovery after injury or surgery

Volleyball coach defies odds to survive cardiac arrest from myocarditis

well ahead logo

Content you want, delivered to your inbox

Want to get the latest health and wellness articles delivered right to your inbox? 

Subscribe to the Well Ahead Newsletter.

Man smiling looking at his phone
Give feedback
Your input is valuable to us.
Please take a moment to share your feedback about your experience on our website today.